The High Court in Britain has declared that the U.K. government acted unlawfully when it classified Palestine Action, a protest organization, as a terrorist entity, a ruling that has resulted in the detention of thousands of peaceful demonstrators.
“This was a truly significant moment,” stated Yasmine Ahmed, the U.K. director of Human Rights Watch, during an interview with As It Happens guest host Nora Young following the ruling on Friday.
“Many of us present in the courtroom felt overwhelming joy and relief.”
However, she emphasized that the struggle is not yet concluded. The prohibition is still active while the U.K. government prepares an appeal, leaving the fate of protesters charged under the Terrorism Act uncertain.
“I plan to contest this ruling”: Home Secretary
Huda Ammori, co-founder of Palestine Action and the plaintiff in the case, described the verdict as “a monumental win for our fundamental rights in Britain and for the fight for freedom for the Palestinian people.”
Ammori praised the court for “overturning a decision that will be remembered as one of the most severe assaults on free speech in recent British history.”

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has announced plans to appeal the High Court’s decision against classifying Palestine Action as a terrorist group. ( Leon Neal/Getty Images)
In contrast, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood expressed her disappointment with the court’s ruling and disagreed with the idea that prohibiting this organization is excessive.
She contended that while the terrorism designation restricts support for Palestine Action, it does not inhibit broader protests in support of Palestinians.
“I plan to contest this ruling,” Mahmood asserted.
The Board of Deputies of British Jews and the Jewish Leadership Council issued a joint statement expressing their “deep concern” regarding the court’s decision.
“We acknowledge the crucial role of judicial oversight in matters concerning national security and civil liberties,” it stated. “Nonetheless, the real-world consequences of Palestine Action’s actions on Jewish communal life have been considerable and deeply troubling.”
Palestine Action is opposed to the U.K. military support for Israel’s actions in Gaza.
Following the attack by Hamas and other militants on October 7, 2023, which resulted in approximately 1,200 fatalities and the abduction of 251 hostages, Israel’s Defense Forces have launched extensive airstrikes and a ground offensive in Gaza that have led to 71,824 deaths and displaced over 73,000 individuals, according to the United Nations.
South Africa has accused Israel of genocide in Gaza before the International Court of Justice in The Hague, an assertion supported by the human rights organization Amnesty International. Israel has consistently and vehemently rejected these claims.
Arrests for sign-holding
The U.K. government designated Palestine Action as a terrorist organization following an incident where activists breached a Royal Air Force base in June and damaged two aircraft, resulting in £7 million ($13 million CAD) in damages.
The U.K. definition of terrorism encompasses acts that involve “serious property damage” intended to influence governmental entities or intimidate the public.
In Canada, however, property damage is classified as terrorism only if it is likely to result in death or bodily harm.

Approximately 2,700 demonstrators have been detained for supporting Palestine Action, with around 700 facing charges under the Terrorism Act. (Toby Shepheard/AFP/Getty Images)
With the classification of the group as a terrorist organization, akin to al-Qaeda and Hamas, supporting or being a member of Palestine Action can lead to a prison sentence of up to 14 years.
Since this designation, British authorities have detained roughly 2,700 individuals for protesting while displaying signs proclaiming “I support Palestine Action.” Nearly 700 of those arrested have been charged under the Terrorism Act, though none have yet faced conviction.
The exact number of individuals still facing charges or who have been released without charges is unclear.
The Metropolitan Police of London announced that, following the ruling, officers would refrain from arresting individuals expressing support for Palestine Action but would continue to collect evidence of offenses “to enable future enforcement.”
Human Rights Watch, an international NGO, asserts that the legislation undermines individuals’ fundamental rights to express themselves, assemble, and be acknowledged.
“We document repression in the name of counter-terrorism globally, from Turkey to Egypt to Hungary,” Ahmed remarked.
“We did not anticipate witnessing this occurring on the streets of the United Kingdom under the auspices of its government.”
The fight continues
In their ruling, Judges Victoria Sharp, Jonathan Swift, and Karen Steyn determined that the terrorism classification is “disproportionate” relative to the actual threat posed by the organization.
“Only a very limited number of Palestine Action’s actions qualified as acts of terrorism,” the judges stated.
“The type and extent of Palestine Action’s conduct that fits the terrorism definition has not reached the necessary level, scale, and duration to justify such a ban.”

Yasmine Ahmed, the U.K. director of Human Rights Watch, argues that the terror designation of Palestine Action represents government overreach intended to suppress free expression. (Benjamin Cremel/AFP/Getty Images)
The judges have allowed until February 20 for lawyers from both sides to prepare for the next hearing.
While Ahmed celebrates the court’s victory on Friday, she remains concerned for those still facing charges or awaiting their trials as the government readies its appeal.
“We received calls today from several individuals who have been arrested, including some charged with terrorism offenses for merely holding signs, who are understandably very anxious and distressed,” she mentioned.
“We hope the courts will proceed swiftly.”

