The attempt by the opposition NDP to initiate an independent public inquiry into the government’s handling of a wildfire that devastated a northern Saskatchewan village has been thwarted. The motion presented by Saskatchewan NDP MLA Jordan McPhail was rejected by the provincial government during its introduction on Tuesday. McPhail has been at the forefront of the NDP’s campaign to seek answers regarding the wildfire that swept through Denare Beach, Sask., in June, resulting in the destruction of over 200 residences.
Instead of the proposed public inquiry, the provincial government is emphasizing the independent review of the 2025 wildfire season that was recently announced. MNP has been tasked with conducting the review, which will provide a platform for individuals directly impacted by the wildfires to share their stories and viewpoints, with the findings to be publicly disclosed.
McPhail expressed dissatisfaction with the government’s response, stating that the selection of voices in the review process speaks volumes on its own. The government’s decision has not been well-received by residents of Denare Beach, some of whom were present at the legislature session on Tuesday. Tasha Young, who lost her home and business in the fire, initially had faith in the government following Premier Scott Moe’s belated apology for not promptly visiting Denare Beach. However, she now deems the government’s rejection of a public inquiry as “unbelievable,” questioning the motive behind withholding the answers sought by many.
In a similar vein, Dustin Trumbley, a Denare Beach resident, reiterated his call for Public Safety Minister Tim McLeod to step down from his position, suggesting that Moe should take the initiative to seek McLeod’s resignation. Trumbley voiced concerns over McLeod’s performance, alleging that he is incapable of fulfilling his duties effectively.
Rhonda Werbicki, another resident whose home was lost in the wildfire, expressed bewilderment over the government’s reluctance to heed the demands for an inquiry. Werbicki questioned the government’s true commitment to assisting the northern community, pondering why they would avoid a public inquiry if they genuinely provided all possible support.