Uncertainty Swirls Around Federal Anti-Hate Bill C-9 Amid Stalled Talks

Date:

Share post:

The fate of the federal government’s anti-hate legislation, Bill C-9, remains uncertain as Justice Minister Sean Fraser’s office has reached an agreement with the Bloc Québécois without securing approval from the Prime Minister’s Office, according to sources speaking to CBC News.

Bill C-9 aims to introduce new offenses under the Criminal Code, including a provision that would criminalize the intentional promotion of hatred against identifiable groups in public while using specific hate or terrorism-related symbols.

Additionally, it aims to categorize hate-motivated crimes as a distinct offense and intensify measures against willfully intimidating and obstructing individuals outside places of worship.

However, in a minority government context, the Liberals require support to advance the bill. It is scheduled for a detailed examination in the justice committee, which includes members from the Liberals, Conservatives, and Bloc Québécois.

Yves-François Blanchet, the leader of the Bloc Québécois, informed reporters last week that his party had negotiated a deal with the Liberals to revise the Criminal Code by eliminating a religious exemption from Canada’s hate speech regulations. This agreement was initially reported by the National Post.

Three sources disclosed to CBC News that the progress of the bill has been hindered because Justice Minister Sean Fraser’s office reached the agreement with the Bloc without the Prime Minister’s Office’s consent.

The negotiation to amend the bill encountered obstacles as it had not received the necessary approval from the prime minister.

CBC News has agreed to keep the identities of the sources confidential, as they were not authorized to publicly discuss internal decisions.

Committee meeting scheduled for Tuesday

On Monday afternoon, a late notice was issued for a justice committee meeting to finalize the clause-by-clause review of the bill on Tuesday. This notice followed the cancellation of committee sessions by the Liberals the previous week.

A spokesperson for Fraser stated that there is no conflict with the Prime Minister’s Office.

“Minister Fraser maintains regular communication with the prime minister. We are collaborating closely on several key issues, including this one,” said spokesperson Jeremy Bellefeuille.

“Our offices work together as intended, and internal discussions are completely standard in a minority Parliament as we engage with all parties, including the Bloc.”

Blanchet mentioned last week that his party would not endorse the bill unless the religious exemption is removed. The Conservatives are against both the proposed amendment and the current form of the bill.

The Bloc has consistently pushed to eliminate the religious exemption, arguing that it could be misused to justify hate speech, including homophobia and antisemitism.

In 2023, Blanchet presented a private member’s bill, C-367, aiming to revise the Criminal Code to abolish the “good faith” religious exemption.

A source from Parliament familiar with the discussions indicated that there is an amendment proposed at the justice committee that utilizes similar wording.

However, the announcement of the agreement between the Liberals and the Bloc Québécois has led religious organizations, including Catholic and Muslim groups, to voice concerns, stating it could intimidate or even criminalize religious expression.

“I believe all Canadians can see that this is a matter that impacts everyone, including both religious and secular Canadians,” remarked Haseeb Hassaan, spokesperson for the National Council of Canadian Muslims.

Simultaneously, five Jewish organizations, including the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), issued a joint statement urging lawmakers to progress the bill, highlighting a “level of hate and intimidation unlike anything in recent memory.”

“There is an urgent need for coordinated action from Parliament to enhance the response of law enforcement and prosecutors, sending a definitive message that hateful extremism is unacceptable in Canada,” stated Noah Shack, CEO of CIJA.

It remains uncertain whether the Liberals will support the Bloc’s proposed amendment on Tuesday.

Ontario Conservative MP Andrew Lawton expressed that he is not surprised by the uncertainty surrounding the agreement’s future.

“I think the Liberals are aware of the millions of Canadians they have alienated through this agreement, which undermines long-established religious protections that will inevitably infringe on individuals’ rights to practice their faith,” he stated in an interview.

A man in a suit holds papers as he speaks inside of a legislature.

Bloc Québécois MP Rhéal Fortin asserts that the government should have honored the agreement made by the minister with the Bloc. (Justin Tang/The Canadian Press)

Bloc Québécois MP Rhéal Fortin, a member of the justice committee, described the situation as disappointing and atypical.

“When a minister has reached an agreement, that minister represents the government, and one would typically expect that to be secure,” he commented.

The new chair of the committee, MP James Maloney, noted last week that he canceled the initial clause-by-clause meeting due to “high emotions and the lack of a clear way forward in addressing such significant legislation.”

The House of Commons is scheduled to adjourn later this week for the holidays and will not reconvene until January 26.

Source

Related articles

Neutrality in Focus: Gumennik Shines Amid Olympic Controversy

As Russian figure skater Petr Gumennik performed his free skate at the Milano-Cortina Winter Games on Friday evening,...

Ivanie Blondin Claims Emotional World Cup Victory in Calgary Finale

Canadian speed skater Ivanie Blondin's triumph in a World Cup mass start on Sunday was particularly meaningful as...

Russell Brand Sentenced to Over 10 Years for Rape and Assault

Russell Brand, the comedian who once held a prominent position in British broadcasting and had a brief stint...

Prince George Woman Sentenced to Life for Fatal Courthouse Stabbing

A woman from Prince George, B.C., has been sentenced to life imprisonment without the chance of parole for...